|
|
Post by RawManiac on Aug 10, 2005 4:09:08 GMT -5
ONLY THE APPOINTED DECK CLINIC "EXPERTS" MAY REPLY TO A USERS THREAD HERE. ADMINS/MODS/ AND THE RESPECTED USER MAY ALSO REPLY HERE. BUT NO OTHER MEMBERS ARE ALLOWED. IF ANY MEMBERS ARE CAUGHT POSTING HERE, YOUR COMMENT WILL BE DELETED AND A WARNING WILL BE ISSUDED. THIS IS SO THE DECK CLINIC DOES NOT GET FLOODED WITH POSTS. IF YOU WANNA REPLY TO A THREAD, PLEASE DO SO ON THE "SUBMIT YOUR DECK" FORUM WHICH WAS MADE ESPECIALLY FOR THAT REASON....
THANK YOU,
- THE SUPERBOARDS STAFF
|
|
|
|
Post by destroyer on Aug 11, 2005 1:28:54 GMT -5
I think its wrong to create this rule.
First off everyone has the right to help other people. The deck clinc was created for people looking for help to adjust there decks. Everyone on this board is here to help. Not just the experts. Quite frankly some of the experts are real horrible deck builders. Some of these experts pack two of the same cards in rene or put an oversell in Rattlenake. My point is that really some of those people you don't consider experst are great deck builders and can provide useful info. Of course I agree the infor they provide should be something useful and not already mentioned.
|
|
metallica
Mid-Carder
Deck Clinic "Expert"
Posts: 318
|
Post by metallica on Aug 11, 2005 1:35:22 GMT -5
Well me being an Mod of that clinic. I cannot say much. But assuming that ur herb lavato, u should post a deck to get on the deck clinic team. The people who post their ideas or decks on the deck clinic thread are looking for "expert" help. And the way that all it's members got on the team was by showing their deck building skills. This making us experts of the game. And if people want expert help, that's what we offer. Expert help, and that's what we give them. Sorry if it makes u mad, but it's the sites rules
|
|
|
|
Post by destroyer on Aug 11, 2005 2:32:21 GMT -5
Its more like Herb Lovato. Barron spelled it wrong in his report last year but its just a last name. So whatever.
Anyways back to my point. By imposing this rule you take away the vaulable resource people can use from a non expert person. I am consider a non expert player. Why don't I get to help people even if I'm extremely helpful? Why should someone who has build decks that contain illegal cards be considered an expert over someone like me? Sure I could post my deck and get put on the expert team (which would probably happen or else you guys were rubed the wrong way by me and don't want me on the "team") but that still doesn't solve my problems with the boards. There are others like me how have great ideas to share and help people but can't because of this rule. This is why I have a problem with the rule
Otherwise keep it like you have it. We could always pm the person and give him our two cents if we liked. Maybe I might even start making this my servince. Pm me your deck and I will provided some help kinda thing.
|
|
|
|
Post by RawManiac on Aug 11, 2005 2:50:43 GMT -5
Herber, read the new "submit your deck/deck critic" thats now for people who are not experts to reply to other peoples decks.
|
|
|
|
Post by Ace Rimmer, Attorney at Large on Aug 11, 2005 4:24:32 GMT -5
if you want to be on the Deck Clinic Staff, contact me, submit a deck to the contest, you have untill Wed at 11:59pm Pacific Daylight Time.
|
|
|
|
Post by destroyer on Aug 11, 2005 10:29:20 GMT -5
if you want to be on the Deck Clinic Staff, contact me, submit a deck to the contest, you have untill Wed at 11:59pm Pacific Daylight Time. Already turn down the position Ace, thanks for asking anyways. Rawmanaic told me he can make me part of the expert team since he knows that I would be a great help but I could still help people by Pm them with my ideas. Yes I still think the rule should be abolish but you guys do whatever you think is best. As for eveybody else I encourage you guys to Pm the people posting in this forum with your ideas to make them a better deck. They can regulate this forum but they can't regulate Pm's |
|
|
|
Post by Ace Rimmer, Attorney at Large on Aug 11, 2005 20:12:12 GMT -5
this is true, but if you are looking for help from one of the certified Deck Clinic Experts, post here. if you are looking for help from anyone, either PM someone, or you can feel free to post in the other forum, there anyone can help you. Destroyer, you miss the point, sure we can not regulate PMs, but there is an entire other forum for help on decks where anyone can help you.
|
|
|
|
Post by RawManiac on Aug 12, 2005 0:23:14 GMT -5
Destroyer is just being hard headed and does this to amke my life harder. Plus he likes to stir up rallys AGAINST the admins and mods. Just the way he works. He means no harm but just to annoy us.
|
|
|
|
Post by destroyer on Aug 12, 2005 0:31:32 GMT -5
Well when I first posted there was only one deck clinic. The other board was a I'm showing off my really good deck come and net deck from me board. Even the board description said that the other board was only for showing off you decks not for modifying or helping.
Now this leads me to my other question Why have two boards one were everybody can post and another were only a couple of people can post(even though no one is following the rule) and just have one where everybody can post. People can still seek help and get the expert help they want. I don't see how one board will prevent experts from helping out.
Lets look at it a different way. What if we did the same thing done here with any other forum? Lets say the Raw Deal Discussion board was divided into two sections one for everyone to post and one for only experts to post. Isthe expert board useless? Yes. Do you see why having an expert section and a regular section is a waste of space and stupid? I know tco does the same thing but not everything tco does is the right way.
|
|
metallica
Mid-Carder
Deck Clinic "Expert"
Posts: 318
|
Post by metallica on Aug 12, 2005 1:20:40 GMT -5
Like I said, you have proved yourself to be a good player. This is why the chance is up there for u to be apart of the deck clinic team. But sadly, you declined. The deck review is for everyone. If we just had the deck clinic and that was it, I could totally see where your coming from, but we do have another forum. Were not saying that were better than you, we just have proved our skills and would like to show our expert skills to people who need it.
That's a Lock, and a joke
What do you call alot of white people chasing one black guy??
The PGA Golf Tour
|
|
